Distinct Violations Draw Judicial Sanction
The Florida Supreme Court has ordered a ten day suspension without pay of a judge
The second amended stipulation would resolve three Commission cases pending against Judge Moon. Judge Moon first admits that, from the bench and while wearing her robe, she asked an attorney why he had not returned her call about serving on her re-election committee. The attorney had just completed a hearing before the judge, and the question left the attorney concerned about whether his failure to support Judge Moon’s campaign would hurt his clients. Second, Judge Moon admits that she engaged in ex parte communication with the mental health therapist of a party in a divorce case pending before her. Finally, Judge Moon admits that between 2020 and 2024 she made financial contributions totaling approximately $2,000 to political organizations and candidates, including ActBlue and the campaign funds of President Biden and Vice President Harris.
Judge Moon’s conduct implicates multiple provisions of the Code of Judicial Conduct. Judges must always act in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary. Fla Code Jud. Conduct, Canons 1 & 2A. Except in limited circumstances, judges may not engage in communication about a pending or impending proceeding outside the presence of the parties. Id. Canon 3B(7)(a). And judges may not make financial contributions to political organizations or candidates. Id. Canon 7A(1)(e). Judge Moon’s acknowledgement that she has violated these canons is amply supported by the record.
Our Court does not often come upon a judicial discipline case in which a single judge has violated the Code of Judicial Conduct in such distinct ways in wholly unrelated incidents. Judge Moon’s conduct is unacceptable, especially given that the Commission had already cautioned her in 2019 for improper campaign activities. Nonetheless, the Commission’s recommended discipline in this matter credits Judge Moon for cooperation, remorse, and acceptance of responsibility. While we defer to the Commission’s assessment of the judge’s contrition, we stress that the Court cannot tolerate any further misconduct by Judge Moon.
We approve the Second Amended Stipulation and Amended Findings and Recommendations of Discipline in this matter. Judge Moon is hereby suspended from her judicial duties for 10 days without pay, effective on a date within 30 days of the issuance of this opinion and as determined by the Chief Judge of the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit. We order Judge Moon to pay a fine of $2,115.40, an amount equal to her improper political contributions. And finally, we order Judge Moon to appear before this Court for the administration of a public reprimand at a time to be established by the Clerk of this Court.
(Mike Frisch)